Because Google fills those three map spots using three things, and your competitor scores better on at least one of them. Google describes them as relevance, distance and prominence. In plain terms, how well your profile matches what was searched, how close you are to the person searching, and how well known your business looks, which mostly means reviews. The map results come from your Google Business Profile rather than your website, so the profile is where the fix lives.
Distance
The map results change with where the searcher is standing. Someone searching from Joondalup sees Joondalup businesses. If your competitor is closer to the suburb where most searches happen, they will appear there and you will not, and no amount of work changes the map. Check this before anything else by searching from a few different suburbs, or by asking friends in different areas to search and tell you what they see.
If you work from home or travel to customers, your profile should be set as a service area business with your address hidden and your suburbs listed. Getting this wrong in either direction, showing a home address you do not serve customers from or hiding an address customers do visit, costs you placements.
Category match
Every profile has one primary category and can have several more. The primary category carries most of the weight. If yours says Contractor and your competitor’s says Electrician, they appear for electrician searches and you do not. Open your profile, look at the primary category, and ask whether it is the most specific one that describes what you do. Then look at the competitor’s, which is visible on their listing.
The same goes for the services and the description. Google reads them. A profile with the services filled in and a plain description of what the business does matches more searches than one with only a name and a phone number.
Reviews
Reviews do most of the work for prominence. Google looks at how many, the average rating, how recently the last one arrived, and whether the business replies. A business with a steady trickle of recent reviews beats one with a burst from two years ago. Reply to every review, including the bad ones, in a calm sentence or two.
What to do next
Compare your profile with the competitor’s on those three points, in that order. Distance you cannot change, category takes a minute, reviews take a system. Our local SEO service works on exactly these profile and review factors for Perth businesses. If you are not sure your profile is set up at all, start with what a Google Business Profile is and whether you need one.
I have more reviews than them, so why are they above me?
Usually distance or category. Reviews only count once the first two are right.
Does my website matter for the map results?
A little. The profile links to it, and a site with a page for that service and suburb helps confirm what the profile says. The profile does most of the work.
Can I pay to appear in the map results?
Google sells advertising that appears near the map, marked as sponsored. The three unpaid spots cannot be bought.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
