Usually because of one of a handful of things, and you can check each one yourself in an afternoon. Google ranks pages rather than businesses. The competitor above you most likely has a page that matches the search more closely, more and newer reviews, more mentions across the web, or a site that loads faster on a phone.
The handful of things it usually is
They have a page for that exact search. If someone searches for emergency plumber Joondalup and your competitor has a page about emergency plumbing in Joondalup while you have one page listing every service, their page wins. One page per service is the biggest difference between sites that rank and sites that do not.
They have more reviews, and newer ones. For local searches the map results sit above everything else, and review count, rating and how recently the last review arrived all feed into them.
Their business is mentioned in more places. Industry directories, supplier pages, local news. Each mention with a link tells Google the business is real and established.
Their site is faster and works better on a phone. Most searches happen on phones. A site that takes several seconds to show anything, or where the buttons are too small to tap, loses ground to one that does not.
They have been doing this longer. A site that has published something useful every month for years has a head start you close with steady work.
What to do next
Search for your main service and suburb, open the competitor’s page, and compare it to yours against the five points above. Then compare reviews in the map results. The gap is usually obvious. If you would rather have it measured, our SEO services start with exactly that comparison. If you used to be above them and recently dropped, read why your website might have dropped off Google this month first.
Could they be paying Google to be above me?
If the result says Sponsored, yes, and that is advertising rather than ranking. Look at the results below the ads for the real order.
Will a new website fix it?
Only if the new site has the service pages, the speed and the reviews behind it. A new site with the same single page ranks exactly where the old one did.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
