Ask who will hold your passwords, who will own your domain name and your licences, what happens when you leave, and how they will know if something goes wrong before you do. The answers tell you more than any brochure. A good provider answers all ten of the questions below without hesitation. One that bristles at them, or cannot answer, is telling you something.
The ten questions
Who will own our domain name, our Microsoft 365 tenant and our licences? The only acceptable answer is that the business owns all of them and the provider administers them. A provider that registers your domain in their name or sets up your tenant under their account has made leaving difficult, whether they meant to or not.
Where will our passwords and administrator logins be kept, and can we see them? You should be able to get every login at any time. A provider who keeps them in a technician’s head, or in a system you cannot access, is a risk to the business.
What exactly is covered by the monthly fee and what is charged extra? Ask for the list in writing. Worry if the answer is vague, or if everything you mention turns out to be a project.
How will you know something has failed before we tell you? A managed provider monitors backups, updates, security alerts and sign ins. If the answer is that you call them when something breaks, that is break fix support with a monthly fee attached.
How are backups done, where are they kept and when were they last tested by restoring something? Worry if the answer stops after the first part. A backup that has never been restored is a hope, not a backup.
What do you do about security, and against what standard? A provider should be able to name a framework, describe multi factor sign in, patching and restricting administrator rights, and say how far along your business would be. Worry if the answer is a product name.
Who will actually look after us, and what happens when they are away? You want to know whether you get the same people, whether your setup is documented so that someone else can step in, and how after hours problems are handled.
Can we speak to two clients of a similar size? A provider with happy clients will offer them. Worry if they cannot.
What is the contract term and what happens when we want to leave? Look for a handover process in writing, with all passwords, documentation and administrator access returned. Worry about long lock in terms, exit fees, or any suggestion that leaving would be complicated.
Do you sell the products you recommend, and how are you paid? There is nothing wrong with a provider supplying hardware or licences, but you should know where their income comes from, and advice should be explained in terms of your business rather than a product.
Answers that should worry you
Beyond the specific red flags above, be wary of a provider who promises everything, who will not put the scope in writing, who talks about tools rather than outcomes, or who cannot explain their advice in plain language. Be equally wary of the cheapest quote. Monitoring, documentation and testing all take time, and a fee that cannot cover them means they are not being done.
What to do next
If you are comparing providers, ask every one of them the same ten questions and write down the answers. The description of what our managed IT support covers gives you a baseline to compare others against. Question one is the most important of the ten, and we have written about who actually owns your domain name and your website because it so often turns out to be the wrong answer.
Should I ask about certifications?
It does no harm, but ask what the certification means for your business. Partner status with a big vendor says they sell that vendor’s products.
Is a local provider better than a national one?
For a small business, usually. You want someone who can be on site when it matters and who knows your office.
What if my current provider cannot answer these?
Ask anyway, politely. The answers, or the lack of them, will tell you whether to start looking.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
