For a business under about fifty staff, outsourcing is nearly always the better answer. A single IT employee costs a full salary plus superannuation, leave, training and the tools they need, and gives you one person with one set of skills who is sometimes on holiday. A managed provider costs a fraction of that, brings several people with different skills, and is never on leave all at once. Hiring starts to make sense when there is a full week of internal IT work every week, which usually arrives somewhere past fifty staff.
What an employee really costs
The salary is the obvious part. Add superannuation, leave, public holidays, and the cost of covering them when they are away. Add the software they need to monitor and secure your computers, which a provider already owns and spreads across many clients. Add training, because a lone technician who stops learning becomes expensive in a different way. Add the recruitment cost and the risk of hiring the wrong person in a field the owner cannot judge.
Then ask what they will do all day. In a business of twenty people the real IT work is a few hours a week once things are set up properly.
What outsourcing really costs
A managed provider charges a fixed monthly fee, usually per user or per computer, that covers monitoring, maintenance, security and support. The fee for a business of twenty is typically a small fraction of one salary, and it rises as you add staff, so it tracks the business rather than jumping in steps. Projects outside the agreement, such as an office move, are quoted separately.
What you give up is having someone in the building. Most businesses find that remote support fixes almost everything, and a provider who visits when needed covers the rest.
When hiring makes sense
Hire when there is a real full time workload, when the business runs specialised systems that need daily hands on attention, or when someone needs to own IT strategy, vendors and budgets internally. Even then, most businesses at that size keep a managed provider for monitoring, security and after hours cover, and the employee coordinates rather than does everything.
The worst option is the one many small businesses drift into, where the most technical staff member becomes the IT person on top of their real job. Nothing gets done properly, and the business discovers the gaps on the day something fails.
How to compare for your business
Write down the hours of IT work your business generates in a typical month, including the things not being done, such as checking backups and reviewing who has access to what. Price an employee fully loaded. Get a quote for managed support covering the same list. For most businesses under fifty staff the comparison is not close.
What to do next
A conversation about what managed IT support would cover for your size is the quickest way to see the comparison with real numbers. Whichever way you go, the work should be measured against something, and the Essential Eight is the standard we use.
Can I outsource some things and keep an internal person?
Yes. A common arrangement is an internal coordinator for day to day questions and a provider for monitoring, security and anything technical.
Will an outsourced provider know my business well enough?
A good one assigns the same people to your account and documents your setup, so the knowledge does not live in one head.
What if my IT person is leaving?
That is the natural moment to compare. Have a provider assess what they were doing and quote for the same before advertising the role.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
