Yes, they can, and in 2026 it is happening to small businesses in Perth every week. Multi factor authentication (MFA) still stops the vast majority of attacks, so it stays switched on, but the criminals have worked out three ways around the common forms of it. The good news is that each of those ways has an answer, and none of the answers is expensive.
How they get past it
The first method is a fake sign in page that sits between you and Microsoft. You click a link in an email, land on a page that looks exactly like the real Microsoft sign in, type your password and then type the code from your authenticator app. The fake page passes both to the real Microsoft in the same second, signs in as you, and keeps the session. You see a normal looking screen and think nothing of it. Ready made kits that do this are sold to criminals as a monthly subscription, and in May 2026 overseas law enforcement issued a public warning about one aimed squarely at Microsoft 365 accounts.
The second is a stolen session token. Once you have signed in, your browser holds a small file that proves you already passed MFA, so you are not asked again all day. If a scammer gets that file, through a fake page or through a dodgy browser extension, they are signed in as you without ever needing your password or your code.
The third is approval fatigue. The scammer already has your password and triggers sign in after sign in, so your phone buzzes with approval prompts at odd hours until you tap Approve just to make it stop. A variation is the device code trick, where an email asks you to type a short code into a genuine Microsoft page, and doing so approves the scammer’s device.
Why MFA is still essential
None of this means MFA is pointless. A mailbox with no MFA can be taken over by anyone who buys your password from a leaked list, which is a daily event. A mailbox with MFA can only be taken over by someone who tricks you in the moment. That is a much smaller group, and the tricks all rely on you clicking a link or approving a prompt, which training and a few technical settings can address.
What closes the gap
Passkeys are the biggest step. A passkey is a sign in tied to your actual device, your phone or laptop, using your face, fingerprint or PIN. It only works on the real Microsoft address, so a fake page cannot relay it. Microsoft supports passkeys for business accounts, and the authenticator app can hold them. Moving the owner and anyone who handles money onto passkeys first is the sensible order.
Sign in rules do the rest. Microsoft 365 Business Premium includes conditional access, which lets your IT provider say things like “only sign in from a company managed device”, “block sign ins from countries we do not trade with” and “block the device code method entirely”. The law enforcement warning above recommends that last rule specifically. Number matching, where the approval prompt asks you to type a number shown on the sign in screen, is already on by default and defeats most approval fatigue attacks.
Finally, shorten how long a session lasts for the accounts that matter and have someone review sign in logs now and then, so a stolen session is noticed rather than used quietly for months.
What to do next
Working out which accounts are still on text message codes, which can move to passkeys and which sign in rules fit your business is the sort of thing our cyber security service does for Perth businesses. If you are starting from the beginning, our post on what MFA is and why everyone keeps asking about it covers the basics first.
Is a text message code still worth having?
It is better than nothing, but it is the weakest form. Move to the authenticator app at least, and to passkeys where you can.
How would I know if someone got past my MFA?
Common signs are emails you did not send in the Sent folder, rules you did not make, and sign in alerts from places you have not been. Check the recent activity page on your Microsoft account.
Do passkeys cost anything?
No. They are part of your existing Microsoft account. The effort is in setting them up for each person, not in paying for them.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
