Can Two People Share One Mailbox?

Yes. In Microsoft 365 a shared mailbox is built for exactly that. Two or more people open it alongside their own mailbox, see the same inbox and sent items, and reply as the shared address. It costs nothing extra while it stays under the size limit, because nobody signs in to it directly. What you should not do is give two people the same password to one ordinary mailbox, which is how most businesses start and where the trouble comes from.

Why sharing a password is the wrong way

When two people use the same login, the second check at sign in cannot work properly, nobody knows who sent what, and when one of them leaves you have to change a password the other person depends on. It also means the shared account is a licensed user that nobody really owns. A shared mailbox fixes all of that. Each person signs in as themselves and the shared address appears as a second mailbox in their own email program.

What a shared mailbox gives you

  • One inbox that everyone with access sees, so a reply by one person is visible to the others.
  • A shared sent items folder, so you can see what has gone out under the address.
  • Send as the shared address, so the customer sees accounts@ rather than a person’s name.
  • Its own calendar, useful for a bookings or roster address.
  • No password of its own and no licence while it stays under the size limit.

How to set one up

  1. In the Microsoft 365 admin centre, create a new shared mailbox with the address you want, such as accounts@ or bookings@.
  2. Add the people who should see it as members. That gives them full access to read and manage it.
  3. Give each of them send as permission, so replies appear from the shared address rather than their own.
  4. Have each person restart their email program. The shared mailbox appears under their own after a short while, with no further sign in.
  5. On phones, add the shared mailbox inside the email app under the person’s own account.
  6. If you are converting an existing ordinary mailbox that two people were sharing, convert it to a shared mailbox in the admin centre. Every message stays, the password is removed and the licence is freed.

The traps

A shared mailbox does not sort out who is handling what. Two people can both reply to the same customer within minutes of each other. Agree a habit, such as flagging or moving a message when you take it, or use categories. Do not set an automatic reply on a shared address, because it confirms to a scammer that the address is live. And if the mailbox needs to be archived or put on legal hold, or grows past the size limit, it then needs a licence.

When a shared mailbox is the wrong tool

If each person needs their own copy of the message in their own inbox rather than one central copy, you want a distribution group. If the two people need a shared calendar, files and a chat space as well as the mail, a Microsoft 365 group may suit better. For an inbox two people take turns answering, the shared mailbox is almost always right.

What to do next

We set these up as part of looking after a business’s Microsoft 365, including converting licensed mailboxes that two people have been sharing by password. For what you should and should not be paying for, see do I need a licence for info@ or sales@.

Can one of them have access to only part of the mailbox?
Yes. Permissions can be given to single folders rather than the whole mailbox, though it is simpler to give full access and keep anything private in your own mailbox.

Will both people get a notification when mail arrives?
Yes, if their email program is set to show the shared mailbox. On phones it depends on the app and whether the shared mailbox has been added.

Can we see who replied to a message?
The sent item in the shared mailbox records which person sent it, even though the customer sees the shared address.

If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.

Need IT help? Chat with us
DM1
DM1 Assistant
Perth IT Support Guide
Scroll to Top