What Is the Difference Between POP and IMAP, and Which One Am I On?

POP downloads your email to one computer and, by default, removes it from the server, so the mail exists only on that machine. IMAP leaves the mail on the server and shows every device the same folders, so your phone and your computer agree. Both are old ways of collecting mail from a basic mailbox at a hosting company. Neither gives you a shared calendar, shared contacts, a proper backup or modern security, which is why a business mailbox today should be on Microsoft 365 or similar, where the question does not arise.

POP in plain terms

POP was designed for dial up, when you connected briefly, collected your mail and hung up. Your email program pulls the messages down and keeps them locally. If that computer dies, so does your email history. If you set up your phone as well, each device sees a different picture, and sent items only exist on the device that sent them.

IMAP in plain terms

IMAP keeps the mail on the server and your devices show a live view of it. Delete a message on your phone and it is gone on the computer too. This is better, and it is what most hosting company mailboxes use now. It is still only email, with no shared calendar or address book, small mailbox space and basic spam filtering, and when the hosting company has an outage your email is the first thing to break.

How to tell which you are on

  1. Open the account settings in your email program and look at the account type. It will say POP, IMAP, Exchange or Microsoft 365.
  2. If the settings page shows an incoming server and an outgoing server with port numbers, you are on POP or IMAP. A Microsoft 365 account shows none of that.
  3. Look at your phone and your computer side by side. If a message deleted on one is still on the other, or sent items differ, you are almost certainly on POP.
  4. Check who you pay for email. If it is bundled with your website hosting, it is almost always POP or IMAP.

Why neither is right for a business now

A business mailbox needs to be on every device and show the same thing, with calendar and contacts shared across the team, protected by two step sign in, filtered properly for scams, large enough to hold years of mail, backed up, and under the business’s control so a departing staff member’s mail can be kept. POP cannot do any of that and IMAP can do only the first.

How to move

Moving from POP or IMAP to Microsoft 365 is a routine job. The existing mail is copied across, the domain’s mail records are pointed at the new service, and each computer and phone is set up with the modern account method, which needs only the email address and the sign in. The old mailbox is kept for a while in case anything was missed. Done in the right order, no mail is lost and nobody outside the business notices a change.

The part that needs care is POP mail that exists only on one computer. That has to be exported from the computer, since the server never had it, and the computer has to be working when the move happens.

What to do next

If your mail is on a hosting company mailbox and you have noticed messages to customers going astray, our post on why your emails are going to spam explains why that happens more on old setups. Moving a business onto Microsoft 365 is something we do regularly, including the copy of old mail and the setup of every device.

Will I lose my old emails if I move?
No. The old mail is copied into the new mailbox before anything is switched over, including mail that only exists on a POP computer.

Can I keep my email address when I move?
Yes. The address stays the same. Only the service behind it changes.

My email program says Exchange. Is that POP or IMAP?
Neither. Exchange is the modern type used by Microsoft 365. If it says that, you are already on the right kind of mailbox.

If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.

Need IT help? Chat with us
DM1
DM1 Assistant
Perth IT Support Guide
Scroll to Top