Should I Buy a Laptop or a Desktop for the Office?

Buy a laptop with a docking station for anyone who ever works away from their desk, and a desktop for a station that never moves. That one rule settles most of it. The laptop plus dock gives the same big screen, keyboard and mouse as a desktop when the person is in, and goes home or to a client site when they are not. The desktop is cheaper, lasts longer and is harder to lose, which is exactly what a reception desk or a workshop computer needs.

Decide by role, not by preference

Walk through the staff list and ask one question about each person. Do they ever need to work somewhere other than this desk? That includes working from home, visiting clients, taking the computer to a meeting room, and the owner who answers email from the kitchen table. If the answer is yes, laptop. If the answer is no and will stay no, desktop.

Roles that usually suit a desktop are reception, a shared computer in a workshop or clinic room, a point of sale, and any station where several people sign in. Roles that usually suit a laptop are the owner, sales, anyone in a client facing or site based job, and anyone with a hybrid arrangement.

What to buy with a laptop

A laptop on its own is a poor desk computer. The screen is small, the keyboard is cramped and the person ends up hunched over it all day. Buy the dock and the desk setup at the same time, so that the laptop arrives at the desk and plugs in with a single cable.

  1. A docking station that matches the laptop’s connector and provides power, screens, network and the peripherals through one cable.
  2. One or two proper monitors.
  3. A separate keyboard and mouse.
  4. A laptop stand or a monitor arm so the laptop screen can be used as a third display at the right height.
  5. A wired network cable to the dock rather than relying on Wi Fi at the desk.
  6. A business grade model with a warranty that covers the years you expect to keep it.

What a desktop gives you

For the same money a desktop is faster, has more room for memory and storage, and is easier to repair. It sits out of the way, is wired to the network and does not walk out the door. It also tends to last longer, because it does not get dropped, overheated in a car or have a battery that wears out. A small form factor desktop mounted behind the monitor takes almost no room on a reception counter.

What a laptop gives you

A laptop gives the business continuity when the office is unavailable, which stopped being theoretical some years ago. It lets a person take the whole working environment to a client. It also raises the stakes on security. A laptop must be encrypted, must sign in with the business account and must be able to be wiped remotely if lost, and those settings should be in place before it leaves the shop. The dock, screens and peripherals add to the up front cost, so a laptop station usually ends up dearer than a desktop station. That is the price of mobility, and for the right roles it is worth paying.

What to do next

If you are replacing several computers at once, the dock and monitor choices are worth getting right the first time so that every desk is the same and any laptop can plug in anywhere. That is part of our hardware and office setup service. Whichever you choose, it will run the current version of Windows, and if you are adding a printer at the same time, read why a new printer may not install on Windows 11 before you unbox it.

Can I use a laptop as my only computer?
Yes, with a dock and a monitor at the desk. Without those it becomes a strain to work on all day.

Is a desktop more secure than a laptop?
Only in the sense that it stays put. A properly set up laptop with encryption and remote wipe is as safe for the business as a desktop.

Do I need two monitors?
Most office staff work noticeably faster with two. For a role that lives in one program at a time, one large monitor is enough.

If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.

Need IT help? Chat with us
DM1
DM1 Assistant
Perth IT Support Guide
Scroll to Top