Sometimes, and only by going through the platform’s own process. Google removes reviews that break its rules, which include reviews from people who were never customers, reviews from competitors and reviews that are abusive or off topic. It does not remove a review just because it is unfair or one star. The route is report, wait, escalate with evidence, and in the meantime reply calmly so other customers see how you handle it. Anyone who emails offering to remove it for a fee is almost certainly a scammer.
What Google will and will not remove
Google’s rules prohibit fake engagement, conflicts of interest, harassment, hate, and content that is not about a real experience at your business. A review from someone you have never dealt with, a review that describes a different business, or a review that names and insults a staff member all qualify. A review from a real customer who had a bad day and describes it harshly does not, even if you disagree with every word. Knowing this before you report saves a lot of frustration.
The steps, in order
- Do not reply in anger. Write nothing for an hour.
- Check your records. Search the reviewer’s name in your bookings, invoices and emails. If there is no trace, note that.
- Report the review from your Google Business Profile. Choose the reason that fits, usually that it is not based on a real experience or is a conflict of interest.
- Reply publicly, briefly and politely. Say you have no record of this person as a customer and invite them to contact you directly. Other readers will draw their own conclusion.
- Wait. Google handles reports in its own time and does not always say why it decided what it did.
- If the review stays and you have evidence, escalate. Google Business Profile has a further appeal path for rejected reports, and a review that is defamatory can be pursued with a lawyer, though that is slow and costly and rarely worth it for one review.
- Ask your happy customers for reviews. A fake one star review sits very differently among forty good ones than among three.
Beware of paid removal
Soon after a bad review appears, expect emails and calls from people offering to delete it for a fee. Google does not sell review removal, and nobody outside Google can remove one. These operators either do nothing, or file the same report you could file yourself, or post fake positive reviews that can get your whole listing suspended. Ignore them. The same goes for offers to bury the bad review under purchased good ones.
If it is part of a campaign
Several fake reviews in a short time, often from accounts with no other activity, is an attack, and Google treats it more seriously. Report each one, say in each report that it is part of a pattern, and keep screenshots with dates. Former employees and competitors are the usual sources, and the pattern is often obvious.
What to do next
Keeping your listing healthy, replying to reviews and building a steady flow of real ones is part of ongoing local SEO work. For the positive side of the ledger, our post on getting more Google reviews without breaking the rules covers what you can and cannot ask customers to do.
Can I just delete the review myself?
No. Business owners cannot delete reviews on their own listing. You can only report them and reply.
Should I reply to a review I think is fake?
Yes, briefly and without accusation. Say you cannot find a record of them and invite them to contact you. The reply is for everyone else reading.
Will Google tell me when it decides?
Usually a short notice in the profile, but not always, and often with no reason given. Check back on the review itself from time to time.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
