Because someone has your password and is trying to sign in with it. The prompt is your multi factor protection doing its job, which is stopping them at the second step. They are sending the request again and again hoping you will tap approve just to make it stop. Do not approve it. Deny it, change your password, and tell whoever looks after your IT, in that order and today.
What is happening
Your password has leaked somewhere. It may have been reused on a website that was breached, typed into a lookalike sign in page, or guessed. The attacker has entered it correctly, and Microsoft has sent the approval request to your phone. The attacker cannot get past that screen without your help. So they try repeatedly, often late at night or early in the morning, counting on you to be tired, confused or annoyed enough to approve one. This has a name in the security trade, prompt bombing, and it works often enough that attackers keep doing it.
Sometimes the prompts come with a phone call or a message claiming to be from IT or Microsoft, saying there is a problem with your account and asking you to approve the request to fix it. That call is the attacker.
What to do right now
- Deny the prompt. If the app offers a button to report it as suspicious, use that.
- Do not approve it to make it stop. It will stop when the attacker gives up or is locked out.
- Change your password from a device you trust, choosing a long one you have never used anywhere else.
- Tell your IT provider or whoever administers your Microsoft 365. They can see where the attempts came from, sign out every session, and check nothing else was touched.
- If you approved one by accident, say so straight away. That changes the response from prevention to clean up, and the sooner it starts the less there is to clean.
- Change the same password anywhere else you used it, because that is probably where it leaked.
What your administrator should do
Beyond resetting the account, an administrator should check the sign in logs for where the attempts came from, look for any mailbox rules or forwarding that were added, and confirm no new devices or applications were registered. They should also move the account to number matching, where the app asks you to type a number shown on the sign in screen rather than just tap approve. Number matching defeats prompt bombing almost entirely, because the attacker does not have the number, and it is available to every Microsoft 365 business account.
Why this is good news in a way
An unexpected prompt means the protection worked. Without multi factor, the attacker would already be in your mailbox, reading your invoices and preparing to redirect your next payment. The prompt is the alarm going off. Treat it as one.
What to do next
If your business has accounts without multi factor sign in, or accounts that still use plain tap to approve, bringing them up to number matching is a small job under Microsoft 365 and one of the most effective things you can do. If you are not sure whether an attacker got in, our post on the signs your business has been hacked lists what to look for.
Could it be a mistake, like a phone or app trying to sign in?
Occasionally an old device with a saved password causes one prompt. Repeated prompts, prompts at odd hours, or prompts from places you have never been are not a mistake.
I approved one. How bad is it?
It means the attacker was signed in, at least for a while. Change the password immediately and get an administrator to sign out all sessions and check the mailbox. Done quickly, the damage is usually small.
Will changing my password stop the prompts?
Yes. The prompts only happen because the attacker has the current password. Once it is changed, they are back to square one.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
