Just once. Outlook sends your automatic reply one time to each address that emails you while the reply is switched on, then stays quiet for that sender until you turn the reply off and on again. You also decide whether people outside your business receive a reply at all. A customer who emails you four times during a fortnight away gets one reply, on the first message, and nothing after that.
One reply per sender, per absence
Outlook keeps a list of every address that has already been sent the reply. The first message from a sender triggers it. The second and tenth from the same sender do not. This stops your reply triggering their reply and the two mailboxes talking to each other all weekend.
The list is cleared when automatic replies are switched off. If you set a start and end time, the reply turns itself off at the end time and the list clears with it. If you switch the reply off for a day and back on, everyone starts fresh and gets the reply again. That is also the trick to use if you have changed the wording and want a regular contact to see the new version.
Who gets the reply at all
Outlook lets you set two messages. One goes to people inside your organisation, meaning anyone with a mailbox in your Microsoft 365. The other goes to people outside it, and that second message has its own switch. You can send it to anyone outside, only to people in your contacts list, or to nobody outside at all.
The choice matters more than it looks. The inside message can say when you are back and who is covering. The outside message, if you send one, should say much less, because scammers read automatic replies for exactly that detail.
Some senders never get a reply. Newsletters and mailing lists mark their messages as bulk mail, and Outlook does not answer those. Messages that land in junk are not answered either, and Outlook will not reply to another automatic reply, which is the second guard against loops.
What this means in practice
If a client emails during your absence, replies to your automatic message with a question, and then hears nothing, that is working as designed. They were told once. It is worth saying so in the reply, with a line such as “this is an automatic message and you will not receive another”, and giving a way to reach the office, because the sender will not be reminded.
What to do next
The step by step for a start time, an end time and separate inside and outside messages is in our guide to setting up out of office replies in Outlook. If your replies behave differently from this, something in the mailbox setup is unusual and worth a look as part of how we manage Microsoft 365 for Perth businesses.
Why did a colleague get my reply twice?
The reply was switched off and on again between their two emails, or the end time passed and it was restarted. Each restart clears the list.
Can I make it reply to every email instead?
Not with the standard automatic reply. A mailbox rule can reply to every message, but that invites loops and tells a scammer the mailbox is unattended every time they test it.
Does the once per sender rule apply to a shared mailbox too?
Yes. A shared mailbox such as info@ keeps its own list. We generally advise leaving automatic replies off on shared mailboxes altogether.
If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.
