Why Does My Email Program Keep Asking for My Password?

Nearly always it is one of three things. The password your computer has saved is out of date, your Microsoft 365 sign in rules changed and the old saved session is no longer accepted, or the email program itself is an old version that cannot complete the modern sign in. Fix those in order before anyone rebuilds your mail profile, because a rebuild is slow and usually unnecessary.

The three usual causes

A stale saved password is the most common. You changed your password on the website or your phone, but the computer still holds the old one and offers it again and again.

A changed sign in policy is next. When multi factor sign in is turned on for your business, or a security setting is tightened, every existing session is asked to prove itself again. The prompt wants you to sign in once with your authentication app, after which it settles down.

An old version is the third. Microsoft retired the old style of password sign in for email some time ago. A very old email program, or an old mail app on a phone, only knows the old style and keeps asking because the server keeps refusing. No password will ever satisfy it.

What to try, in order

Start by signing in to your mailbox through a web browser. If the password works there, the problem is on the computer. If it does not, reset the password first.

Next, when the prompt appears, type the current password rather than letting the saved one fill in. If it asks for a code from your authentication app, approve it. That single successful sign in clears most cases.

If the prompt keeps returning, remove the saved email credentials from the operating system’s credential store and sign in once more. Then check that the email program is up to date. Only after all of that is it worth rebuilding the mail profile, and by then it is usually faster to have your IT provider do it remotely.

When a prompt is a warning sign

A password prompt that appears out of nowhere, especially one that opens in a browser window on a page you did not navigate to, deserves suspicion. Scammers send emails that mimic a sign in page precisely because people are used to being asked. If the prompt arrived after you clicked a link in an email, close it and sign in to your mailbox from a fresh browser tab instead.

Another warning sign is a prompt that keeps failing even though the web sign in works. That can mean a security lock has been triggered on the account, or that a sign in from another country has been blocked. It is worth a look at the sign in activity rather than another attempt at the password.

What to do next

If the prompt has survived a password reset and an update, ask whoever looks after your Microsoft 365 to check the account’s sign in activity. If you have not yet moved to app based sign in, our guide to setting up the authentication app explains what to expect when the prompt asks for it.

Should I just rebuild my Outlook profile?
Not first. A rebuild will not help if the real cause is a stale password or an old program version.

Why does my phone ask but my computer does not?
The phone is often running an older mail app or an old saved session. Remove the account and add it again with the current password.

Could the prompt mean I have been hacked?
Sometimes. A prompt that follows a link you clicked, or one that fails while the web sign in works, is worth reporting rather than retrying.

If this is happening in your business and you would like it sorted, call DM1 on (08) 6202 6012 or send us a message. We look after IT, Microsoft 365, websites and domain names for Perth small businesses.

Need IT help? Chat with us
DM1
DM1 Assistant
Perth IT Support Guide
Scroll to Top